close

Foodie’s Guide to Fayetteville, WV: Best Eats & Restaurants Nearby

Introduction

Fayetteville, West Virginia, nestled in the heart of the New River Gorge, is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. The allure of the Gorge is undeniable – its rugged cliffs beckon rock climbers, the whitewater rapids of the New River and Gauley River challenge rafters, and the miles of trails entice hikers and mountain bikers. After a day spent conquering these natural wonders, one’s appetite naturally follows suit.

But where to find a satisfying meal after all that exertion? This guide is your ultimate resource for navigating the thriving food scene near Fayetteville, WV. Whether you’re a seasoned local, a first-time visitor eager to explore the culinary landscape, or simply craving a delicious meal, we’ve compiled a comprehensive list of the best restaurants and eateries. We’ll explore everything from quick, casual bites to more upscale dining experiences, offering a range of cuisines and atmospheres to cater to all tastes and budgets. Get ready to discover the flavors that perfectly complement the adventure and beauty surrounding Fayetteville.

The Fayetteville Food Scene: A Quick Overview

The food scene in and around Fayetteville has experienced a significant transformation, mirroring the town’s growth as a premier destination for outdoor recreation. The area’s reputation for adventure has fueled a demand for diverse dining options, catering to the influx of tourists and the evolving preferences of the local community. The result is a vibrant tapestry of culinary choices, from beloved local institutions to innovative new establishments.

The dining landscape near Fayetteville is surprisingly diverse. You’ll find everything from classic American fare to international flavors, offering a taste of the world in the heart of West Virginia. Many establishments emphasize fresh ingredients, with some restaurants sourcing locally-grown produce and meats, adding a unique touch to the dining experience.

As for pricing, you’ll generally find options to suit most budgets. There are plenty of casual eateries offering affordable meals, perfect for refueling after a day of outdoor activities. For those seeking a more special occasion or a more refined dining experience, there are options that provide a more upscale dining experience.

Casual Eats and Quick Bites for Fueling Up

After a day of hiking, biking, or paddling, a quick and delicious meal is often the perfect remedy. Here are some fantastic options for casual eats:

Cathedral Cafe

Located in a beautifully renovated church, Cathedral Cafe offers a warm and inviting atmosphere. Their menu boasts a variety of sandwiches, salads, and soups, perfect for a light lunch or a quick dinner. Known for delicious coffee and pastries, it is an ideal stop for breakfast or a mid-afternoon treat. The cafe also frequently hosts live music, which adds to the charming ambiance. They have great outdoor seating.

Cuisine Type: American, Cafe

Description: Relaxed, welcoming cafe in a historic building. Great for breakfast, lunch, or a coffee break.

Menu Highlights: The breakfast sandwiches, the flavorful salads, and their coffee are all well-loved.

Price Range: Budget-friendly

Why It’s Recommended: Excellent for a quick, satisfying meal or a relaxed coffee experience. The atmosphere is very pleasant.

Pies & Pints Pizzeria

A Fayetteville staple, this restaurant provides a lively environment, perfect for a casual meal with friends or family. Pies & Pints is famous for its creative gourmet pizzas, featuring unique flavor combinations that will tantalize your taste buds. Their extensive beer selection complements the pizzas perfectly. The location in the heart of Fayetteville makes it easily accessible.

Cuisine Type: Pizza, American

Description: Popular pizzeria with a lively atmosphere and creative pizza combinations.

Menu Highlights: Signature gourmet pizzas, with unique toppings. Great selection of craft beers.

Price Range: Budget-friendly to moderate

Why It’s Recommended: Ideal for families, groups, or anyone looking for a delicious and fun meal.

Secret Sandwich Society

This spot offers a laid-back atmosphere, with a focus on gourmet sandwiches, soups, and salads, perfect for a casual lunch or dinner. They are known for their generous portions and use fresh ingredients. Located right in Fayetteville, it’s super convenient to access.

Cuisine Type: Sandwiches, American

Description: A popular and beloved sandwich shop in Fayetteville, WV with delicious, unique options.

Menu Highlights: All sandwiches are excellent. The “Black Diamond” is a top choice.

Price Range: Budget-friendly to moderate

Why It’s Recommended: Great for a quick and tasty meal, and friendly service.

Restaurants with Outdoor Seating and Scenic Views

Enjoying a meal with a view enhances the dining experience, especially when surrounded by the stunning beauty of the New River Gorge.

Bridge Brew Crew

This popular restaurant and brewery offers outdoor seating with views of the New River Gorge Bridge, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a meal and a cold brew. They serve up classic American pub fare, including burgers, sandwiches, and appetizers, alongside their own craft beers. The lively atmosphere and scenic location make this a favorite among both locals and tourists.

Cuisine Type: American, Pub

Description: Casual restaurant and brewery with views of the New River Gorge Bridge. Great for socializing and enjoying the scenery.

Menu Highlights: Burgers, sandwiches, appetizers, and a variety of craft beers brewed on site.

Price Range: Moderate

Ideal For: Relaxing and enjoying the beauty of the bridge, a fun night out, or watching a game.

The Burrito Bar

Offering a fun and casual dining experience, The Burrito Bar allows you to enjoy Mexican food with a view of the New River. With outdoor seating, customers can enjoy the vibrant atmosphere while enjoying great food.

Cuisine Type: Mexican

Description: A fun and casual dining experience. The outdoor seating is great.

Menu Highlights: The menu includes a wide variety of burritos, tacos, and quesadillas.

Price Range: Budget-friendly to moderate

Ideal For: Enjoying a meal with friends and family.

Fine Dining and Special Occasions

For a more upscale experience, Fayetteville offers restaurants that provide elegant settings and refined cuisine.

The Handle Bar

Located at Adventures on the Gorge, The Handle Bar offers a fine dining experience with incredible views. The Handle Bar has an extensive menu, with many locally-sourced ingredients. The atmosphere and the outstanding service make it perfect for special celebrations.

Cuisine Type: American, Fine Dining

Description: Upscale dining experience with exceptional views. Great service.

Menu Highlights: Dishes feature locally-sourced ingredients.

Price Range: Moderate to expensive

Why It’s Recommended: Perfect for a special occasion, a romantic dinner, or a memorable dining experience.

Coffee Shops and Bakeries: Your Daily Dose of Caffeine and Sweet Treats

Fayetteville boasts several excellent coffee shops and bakeries, offering a perfect way to start the day, grab a quick lunch, or indulge in a sweet treat.

Cathedral Cafe

(See above description, also fits well here)

The Freefolk

Offers a great place to get a tasty coffee and is a favorite in the area.

Beyond Fayetteville: Exploring Nearby Dining Options

While Fayetteville offers a fantastic array of dining choices, expanding your search slightly can reveal even more culinary treasures.

Oak Hill

Just a short drive from Fayetteville, Oak Hill provides additional restaurant options.

Beckley

Slightly further afield, the city of Beckley presents an array of restaurants.

Practical Information for Dining Near Fayetteville, WV

Proximity to Activities: Most restaurants in Fayetteville are conveniently located near popular attractions, such as the New River Gorge National Park and Preserve.

Hours of Operation: Restaurant hours can vary, especially during the off-season. It’s always a good idea to check a restaurant’s website or call ahead to confirm their operating hours.

Reservations: Reservations are recommended for fine dining restaurants and those with outdoor seating, especially during peak season.

Take-Out/Delivery: Many restaurants offer take-out options, perfect for grabbing a quick meal on the go.

Accessibility: Restaurants generally strive to be accessible to people with disabilities. Check with individual establishments for specific details regarding accessibility.

Tips for Visitors:

Consider the weather when choosing restaurants with outdoor seating.

Be aware that options may be limited during the busiest tourist seasons. Plan ahead.

Read online reviews and check menus before deciding on a restaurant.

Embrace the chance to try something new! Fayetteville and the surrounding area offer diverse options that will delight your taste buds.

Conclusion

The area near Fayetteville, WV, provides a diverse and delicious culinary landscape. Whether you are looking for a quick bite, a meal with incredible views, or a special dining experience, you can find something to satisfy your cravings. From casual eateries to fine dining establishments, the best restaurants in the area have something for everyone. We hope this guide has helped you to discover the best food near Fayetteville, WV, and that you’ll enjoy exploring the local dining scene. Get ready to experience the wonderful flavors that complement the incredible adventures this area has to offer. Bon appétit, and happy exploring!